Mock HIPAA Auditthe OCR examiner, before the exam

A worked specimen pack, scored

This is a public-safe example security policy run through the review and scored against the 67 HIPAA Security Rule requirements. Every mentioned row quotes the specimen's own words; every open row carries the question an experienced reviewer opens with. Read the whole result without running anything.

What does the worked specimen show?

This is a public-safe example policy run through the review, server-rendered so you can read it without running anything. It reads 19% of the 63 applicable Security Rule requirements as mentioned (12 mentioned, 10 partly, 0 planned only, 15 addressable to decide, 26 not evidenced). Every mentioned row quotes the specimen’s own words; every open row carries the question an experienced reviewer opens with. Run your own pack.

164.306Security Standards: General Rules Provisionnot evidenced

The examiner asks Walk me through how you decide what is reasonable and appropriate for an entity of your size and risk profile, and show where that decision is recorded.

164.308(a)(1)(i)Security Management Process (Standard) Standardnot evidenced

The examiner asks Show me the policies and procedures that prevent, detect, contain and correct security violations, not only the incident form.

164.308(a)(1)(ii)(A)Risk Analysis (Required) Requirednot evidenced

The examiner asks Show me the risk analysis and tell me its date. Walk me through how you scoped the ePHI in it.

164.308(a)(1)(ii)(B)Risk Management (Required) Requirednot evidenced

The examiner asks Show me how each risk above acceptable was treated, and who accepted the residual risk.

164.308(a)(1)(ii)(C)Sanction Policy (Required) Requiredmentioned

Their words: “policy sets out graduated sanctions for non-compliance and is applied with human resources.”

164.308(a)(1)(ii)(D)Information System Activity Review (Required) Requiredpartly

Their words: “The security team reviews access and activity reports each month and records the review.”

The examiner asks Show me the last review of your audit logs, access reports and incident tracking, and tell me the cadence.

164.308(b)(1)Business Associate Contracts and Other Arrangements (Standard) Standardpartly

Their words: “Before any business Associate handles ePHI, a written Business Associate Agreement”

The examiner asks Show me the written assurance you obtained before a business associate handled ePHI.

164.308(a)(2)Assigned Security Responsibility (Standard) Standardpartly

Their words: “Assigned security responsibility.”

The examiner asks Name the security official responsible for these policies, and show me the appointment.

164.308(b)(2)Subcontractor Arrangements Requiredpartly

Their words: “subcontractors.”

The examiner asks Show me how a subcontractor of your business associate is bound to the same safeguards.

164.308(a)(3)(i)Workforce Security (Standard) Standardpartly

Their words: “Workforce security and training.”

The examiner asks Show me how you ensure workforce members have appropriate access and that everyone else is prevented from getting it.

164.308(a)(3)(ii)(A)Authorization and Supervision (Addressable) Addressableplanned

The examiner asks Show me the procedure that authorises and supervises workforce members who work with ePHI.

164.308(a)(3)(ii)(B)Workforce Clearance Procedure (Addressable) Addressablepartly

Their words: “Before access is granted, the clearance procedure confirms that access”

The examiner asks Show me how you determine that access to ePHI is appropriate before it is granted.

164.308(a)(3)(ii)(C)Termination Procedures (Addressable) Addressableplanned

The examiner asks Show me the termination procedure and the last time it ran end to end.

164.308(b)(3)Written Contract or Other Arrangement Requirednot evidenced

The examiner asks Show me the contract or arrangement that documents the assurances.

164.308(a)(4)(i)Information Access Management (Standard) Standardnot evidenced

The examiner asks Show me the policy that authorises access to ePHI consistently with the Privacy Rule.

164.308(a)(4)(ii)(A)Isolating Health Care Clearinghouse Functions (Required if applicable) Required if applicablenot evidenced

The examiner asks If a clearinghouse function sits inside a larger organisation, show me how the ePHI is isolated.

164.308(a)(4)(ii)(B)Access Authorization (Addressable) Addressableplanned

The examiner asks Show me the workflow that grants access to ePHI, from request to provisioning.

164.308(a)(4)(ii)(C)Access Establishment and Modification (Addressable) Addressableplanned

The examiner asks Show me how you document, review and modify a user's right of access over time.

164.308(a)(5)(i)Security Awareness and Training (Standard) Standardnot evidenced

The examiner asks Show me the security awareness and training programme for all workforce members.

164.308(a)(5)(ii)(A)Security Reminders (Addressable) Addressablementioned

Their words: “security awareness training at onboarding and annually, and receive periodic reminders by email.”

164.308(a)(5)(ii)(B)Protection from Malicious Software (Addressable) Addressablementioned

Their words: “against malicious software; workforce members report suspected infections to the service desk.”

164.308(a)(5)(ii)(C)Log-in Monitoring (Addressable) Addressablementioned

Their words: “attempts are monitored and failed-authentication thresholds raise an alert to the security operations desk.”

164.308(a)(5)(ii)(D)Password Management (Addressable) Addressableplanned

The examiner asks Show me the procedure for creating, changing and safeguarding passwords.

164.308(a)(6)(i)Security Incident Procedures (Standard) Standardmentioned

Their words: “known security incidents are identified, contained, eradicated and recovered under the incident response”

164.308(a)(6)(ii)Response and Reporting (Required) Requirednot evidenced

The examiner asks Show me how you identify and respond to a suspected incident, and how you document its outcome.

164.308(a)(7)(i)Contingency Plan (Standard) Standardnot evidenced

Their words: “multi-factor authentication across every ePHI system next year, and the contingency plan has not yet been tested.”

The examiner asks Show me the policy for responding to emergencies that damage ePHI systems.

164.308(a)(7)(ii)(A)Data Backup Plan (Required) Requirednot evidenced

Their words: “There is no data backup plan in place for the legacy laboratory system.”

The examiner asks Show me how you create and maintain retrievable exact copies of ePHI.

164.308(a)(7)(ii)(B)Disaster Recovery Plan (Required) Requiredmentioned

Their words: “A disaster recovery plan describes restoring lost data and resuming”

164.308(a)(7)(ii)(C)Emergency Mode Operation Plan (Required) Requiredmentioned

Their words: “operations, and an emergency mode operation plan describes continuing critical processes with access”

164.308(a)(7)(ii)(D)Testing and Revision Procedures (Addressable) Addressableplanned

The examiner asks Show me the last periodic test of the contingency plan and what changed after it.

164.308(a)(7)(ii)(E)Applications and Data Criticality Analysis (Addressable) Addressableplanned

The examiner asks Show me how you rank the criticality of applications and data, and how that drives backup and recovery.

164.308(a)(8)Evaluation (Standard) Standardmentioned

Their words: “An annual technical and nontechnical evaluation reviews the policies, tests a sample of”

164.310(b)Workstation Use (Standard) Standardnot evidenced

The examiner asks Show me the policy that specifies the proper functions, manner of performance and physical attributes of ePHI workstations.

164.310(c)Workstation Security (Standard) Standardnot evidenced

The examiner asks Show me the physical safeguards that restrict workstation access to authorised users.

164.310(a)(1)Facility Access Controls (Standard) Standardnot evidenced

The examiner asks Show me the policies that limit physical access to systems and facilities while allowing authorised access.

164.310(d)(1)Device and Media Controls (Standard) Standardnot evidenced

The examiner asks Show me how hardware and media holding ePHI are received, removed and moved within the facility.

164.310(a)(2)(i)Contingency Operations (Addressable) Addressablepartly

Their words: “A disaster recovery plan describes restoring lost data and resuming”

The examiner asks Show me the procedure that lets facilities be accessed during disaster recovery and emergency mode.

164.310(a)(2)(ii)Facility Security Plan (Addressable) Addressableplanned

The examiner asks Show me the facility security plan that protects the site and equipment from unauthorised access, tampering and theft.

164.310(a)(2)(iii)Access Control and Validation Procedures (Addressable) Addressableplanned

The examiner asks Show me how you control and validate facility access by role or function, including visitors.

164.310(a)(2)(iv)Maintenance Records (Addressable) Addressableplanned

The examiner asks Show me the records of repairs and modifications to physical security components.

164.310(d)(2)(i)Disposal (Required) Requirednot evidenced

The examiner asks Show me how ePHI and the media it sits on are disposed of.

164.310(d)(2)(ii)Media Re-use (Required) Requirednot evidenced

The examiner asks Show me how ePHI is removed from media before it is reused.

164.310(d)(2)(iii)Accountability (Addressable) Addressableplanned

The examiner asks Show me the record of hardware and media movements and the person responsible for each.

164.310(d)(2)(iv)Data Backup and Storage (Addressable) Addressableplanned

The examiner asks Show me the retrievable exact copy of ePHI made before equipment was moved.

164.312(b)Audit Controls (Standard) Standardmentioned

Their words: “Systems that contain or use ePHI write audit records to a central log platform.”

164.312(d)Person or Entity Authentication (Standard) Standardnot evidenced

Their words: “multi-factor authentication across every ePHI system next year, and the contingency plan has not yet been tested.”

The examiner asks Show me how you verify that a person or entity seeking ePHI is who they claim.

164.312(a)(1)Access Control (Standard) Standardpartly

Their words: “Access control.”

The examiner asks Show me the technical policy that lets only authorised persons or software reach ePHI.

164.312(c)(1)Integrity (Standard) Standardnot evidenced

The examiner asks Show me the controls that protect ePHI from improper alteration or destruction.

164.312(e)(1)Transmission Security (Standard) Standardnot evidenced

The examiner asks Show me the measures that guard ePHI transmitted over a network.

164.312(a)(2)(i)Unique User Identification (Required) Requiredmentioned

Their words: “issued a unique user identifier; shared and generic accounts are prohibited.”

164.312(a)(2)(ii)Emergency Access Procedure (Required) Requirednot evidenced

The examiner asks Show me the procedure for obtaining ePHI during an emergency, and who can invoke it.

164.312(a)(2)(iii)Automatic Logoff (Addressable) Addressablementioned

Their words: “automatically after fifteen minutes of inactivity, and users re-authenticate for sensitive functions.”

164.312(a)(2)(iv)Encryption and Decryption (Addressable) Addressablepartly

Their words: “Authentication and encryption.”

The examiner asks Show me that ePHI is encrypted at rest and how the keys are managed.

164.312(c)(2)Mechanism to Authenticate ePHI (Addressable) Addressableplanned

The examiner asks Show me the mechanism that corroborates ePHI has not been altered.

164.312(e)(2)(i)Integrity Controls for Transmission (Addressable) Addressableplanned

The examiner asks Show me how transmitted ePHI is protected from undetected modification.

164.312(e)(2)(ii)Encryption of Transmissions (Addressable) Addressableplanned

The examiner asks Show me that ePHI transmissions are encrypted, and any place encryption was deemed infeasible.

164.314(a)(1)Business Associate Contracts or Other Arrangements (Standard) Standardnot evidenced

The examiner asks Show me that the contract meets the required provisions of 164.314(a)(2).

164.314(b)(1)Requirements for Group Health Plans (Standard) Standardnot evidenced

The examiner asks Show me that the group health plan's plan documents require the plan sponsor to safeguard ePHI.

164.314(a)(2)(i)Business Associate Contracts Requiredmentioned

Their words: “must be in place requiring the associate to safeguard ePHI, report incidents, and flow the same terms to its”

164.314(a)(2)(ii)Other Arrangements Requirednot evidenced

The examiner asks If both parties are governmental, show me the MOU or law that meets the objective.

164.314(a)(2)(iii)Business Associate Contracts with Subcontractors Requiredpartly

Their words: “subcontractors.”

The examiner asks Show me that the same required provisions flow down to a subcontractor.

164.314(b)(2)Implementation Specifications for Group Health Plans Requirednot evidenced

The examiner asks Show me the plan-document provisions that require the sponsor to implement safeguards and support the required separation.

164.316(a)Policies and Procedures (Standard) Standardnot evidenced

The examiner asks Show me the reasonable and appropriate policies and procedures that implement the Security Rule.

164.316(b)(1)Documentation (Standard) Standardnot evidenced

The examiner asks Show me the written or electronic record of each required action, activity and assessment.

164.316(b)(2)(i)Time Limit (Documentation Retention) Requirednot evidenced

The examiner asks Show me that documentation is retained for six years from creation or last in effect, whichever is later.

164.316(b)(2)(ii)Availability (Documentation) Requirednot evidenced

The examiner asks Show me that the documentation is available to the people responsible for implementing it.

164.316(b)(2)(iii)Updates (Documentation) Requirednot evidenced

The examiner asks Show me the periodic review and the last update made in response to a change affecting ePHI security.